Mesh networking

Wireless mesh network vs mesh Wi-Fi at home

Mesh Wi-Fi at home is a set of access points that link to each other, by cable or by radio, to spread one Wi-Fi network across a building, while phones and laptops stay ordinary clients of the nearest access point. A wireless mesh network in the wider sense is one in which the devices themselves relay traffic for each other, so it can work with no access points at all.

TL;DR

Home mesh Wi-Fi spreads one network across a building with access points that relay over a backhaul, while your phone stays an ordinary client. A device-to-device mesh has phones or sensors carry each other's messages with no installed hardware. Choose home mesh Wi-Fi for coverage, and a device mesh when there is no access point, power or internet.

Learning objectives

After reading this article you will be able to:

  • Distinguish home mesh Wi-Fi from a mesh in which devices relay for each other
  • Explain why a phone on home mesh Wi-Fi never relays for other devices
  • Choose between home mesh Wi-Fi and a device-to-device mesh for a given goal

Home mesh Wi-Fi vs wireless mesh network

Home mesh Wi-Fi and a wireless mesh network differ in which devices relay: in home mesh Wi-Fi only the access points do, while in a wireless mesh network the devices themselves pass traffic along. “Mesh” is used for two quite different setups, and the difference matters when you are deciding what will work without infrastructure.

  • Home mesh Wi-Fi is a product category: several access points placed around a house or office that work together as one Wi-Fi network. Your phone, laptop and television connect to them the way they would connect to any router.
  • A wireless mesh network in the general sense is one in which the devices themselves pass traffic along for each other. There may be no access point at all. A mesh network of phones, sensors or radios is this second kind.

Both use the mesh idea of many links instead of one centre.

Home mesh Wi-Fi and EasyMesh

Home mesh Wi-Fi uses several access points, linked by a backhaul, that work together as one network. A single router may not cover a whole home. The Wi-Fi Alliance’s technology overview of EasyMesh notes that walls, floors and wiring affect coverage, and that the number of connected devices adds traffic. Mesh systems answer this with more access points.

Wi-Fi EasyMesh is the Wi-Fi Alliance’s standards-based approach to networks with multiple access points. In its description, EasyMesh access points work together to form a unified network, guide devices to the best access point, and change the network’s structure as conditions change. It is also meant to let access points from more than one vendor join the same network.

The links between the access points are often called the backhaul. prplMesh, an open-source EasyMesh implementation from the prpl Foundation, describes its backhaul handling as preferring wired connections for reliability and falling back to wireless when needed. The same project lists settings such as network names and passphrases syncing across all the nodes, and steering devices to the best access point.

IEEE 802.11s is a separate standard. It is the IEEE amendment that describes how 802.11 stations form self-configuring multi-hop networks, and router software such as OpenWrt supports it, so it is one way to build the wireless links between access points.

Phones as clients on home mesh Wi-Fi

A phone does not relay traffic on home mesh Wi-Fi: it is an ordinary Wi-Fi client. It joins one access point at a time, and the access points decide how its traffic crosses the backhaul. The phone never forwards traffic for the laptop in the next room.

That has two consequences. Coverage ends where the access points end; step outside their range and your devices lose the network, even if another phone is a few metres away. And if the access points lose power, the network is gone for every device at once.

Device-to-device mesh networks

In a device mesh, every participant can relay. The Bluetooth SIG’s mesh FAQ describes a network with no central hub or routing nodes in which messages travel over multiple paths, with mains-powered nodes relaying for others. RFC 2501 describes mobile ad hoc networks as mobile nodes that route for each other with no fixed infrastructure, a model covered in what is a mobile ad hoc network.

Phones can join this kind of mesh too, using software that runs on each device. Wi-Fi itself also has device-to-device modes: the Wi-Fi Alliance describes Wi-Fi Direct as letting devices create their own networks with no access point, and Wi-Fi Aware as direct device-to-device connections without traditional network infrastructure. Those give devices direct links; relaying a message across several devices is left to the software above them. Can phones form a mesh network without internet? covers what that software has to do.

Home mesh Wi-Fi vs device-to-device mesh comparison

Home mesh Wi-Fi needs installed access points and covers one network in a building, while a device-to-device mesh needs no installed hardware and keeps devices talking where infrastructure is missing or down.

Home mesh Wi-FiDevice-to-device mesh
Who relaysAccess points onlyThe devices themselves
Your phone’s roleClient of one access pointA node that can forward for others
Needs installed hardwareYes, the access pointsNo
Main purposeCoverage for one network and internet line in a buildingCommunication where infrastructure is missing or down
Example standardsWi-Fi EasyMeshBluetooth Mesh, IETF MANET protocols

Choosing home mesh Wi-Fi or a device mesh

If the goal is good Wi-Fi and internet in every room, a home mesh is the right tool, and EasyMesh is the standard to look for if you want to mix vendors.

If the goal is for devices to reach each other when there is no access point, no power, or no internet, a home mesh does not help, because every device still depends on the access points. That needs a device-to-device mesh, where the phones or sensors carry each other’s messages.

Frequently asked questions

Can my phone join a home mesh Wi-Fi network as a relay?

No. In a home mesh, the access points carry traffic between themselves, and a phone connects to one of them as an ordinary client. The phone does not forward traffic for other devices.

What is Wi-Fi EasyMesh?

Wi-Fi EasyMesh is the Wi-Fi Alliance's standards-based approach to networks with multiple access points. EasyMesh access points work together to form a unified network and guide devices to the best access point, and it is meant to let access points from more than one vendor join the same network.

Does home mesh Wi-Fi keep working if the power goes out?

No. If the access points lose power, the network is gone for every device at once, because phones and laptops connect only through them.

What is the backhaul in a mesh Wi-Fi system?

The backhaul is the set of links between the access points. prplMesh, an open-source EasyMesh implementation, describes its backhaul handling as preferring wired connections for reliability and falling back to wireless when needed.

Can Wi-Fi Direct connect phones into a mesh?

Wi-Fi Direct lets devices create their own networks with no access point, which gives them direct links. Relaying a message across several devices is left to the software above it.

Sources

Build it with Offline Protocol

The platforms and transports page lists which radio and network paths the Offline Protocol mesh SDK supports on each surface in v0.33.0, and what each path needs before deployment.

Read platforms and transports